Roof repairs old roof replacement with new shingles of an apartment

Roof Restoration vs. Roof Replacement: Which Is Better?

When your roof is over 20 years old, it’s time to plan any necessary repairs or replacements. If your roof is made of asphalt, it will probably last about 20 years, but many other factors play a role in its lifespan. A professional roof inspector can tell you if your roof needs any repairs or if it will need to be replaced altogether. 

Roof Restoration vs. Roof Replacement: Which Is Better?

While roof replacements offer homeowners a chance to fix roofing problems such as leaks and shingles that are falling off, roof restorations also have their own set of advantages. So, if your home’s roof is nearing the point of failure, it’s a good idea to weigh the pros and cons of each.

Roof Restoration

Although a roof restoration is more expensive than a roof replacement, it is also more appealing for a number of reasons – primarily because it reinvigorates your roof without changing the appearance of your home. Also, in most cases, a roof restoration can be completed without disturbing your interior, meaning you won’t have to deal with the mess that is associated with most roof replacements.

Roof Replacement

On the other hand, a roof replacement can offer a more affordable option for homeowners experiencing extreme leaks. Also, if your roof is in such bad shape that it’s affecting your home’s resale value, a replacement may be the best option.

When to Have a Roof Restored

If your roof is in good condition, but you need to take precautionary measures to ensure it doesn’t fail in the future, you should consider having it restored. Although a roof restoration is more expensive than a roof replacement, it can be well worth the added expense if your roof is more than ten years old and has faded colors, dirty and cracked granules, worn-out drip edges, and missing shingles.

When to Have a Roof Replaced

If your roof has been damaged due to a storm, fire, or negligence, a replacement will be in order. Also, if more than 50 percent of your roof is damaged, it will need to be replaced because you’ll never be able to fix it. Finally, if you live in an area that receives a lot of snow, you’ll probably need to replace your roof in order to ensure that you don’t have to deal with a leaky roof in the future.

Calling a Professional

While you may be tempted to take on your roof replacement or restoration yourself, this isn’t a job for the do-it-yourselfer. That’s because it can be dangerous for you and your family if you try to head up this big job by yourself. So, if you’re uncertain about taking on the project, it’s best to call a professional.


When your roof is in need of some TLC, it’s important to choose the right option. So, if you’re not sure whether a roof replacement or restoration is right for you, call a professional roofing company to help you make the right decision.

Work with experienced roofing contractors in Birmingham, AL, by calling 5 Star Roofer today! We provide residential roofing, complete roof tear-offs, and commercial flat roofing systems in the Greater Birmingham Area. We offer Industry-leading manufacturers and labor warranties. Interested parties may call us or email us today!

Birmingham, AL

209 Oxmoor Circle
Birmingham, AL 35209

(205) 518-8433

Mobile, AL

601 Bel Air Blvd
Suite 209
Mobile, AL 36606

(251) 405-3553

Madison, AL

7169 US-72,
Suite A #102
Madison, AL 35758

(256) 210-1700

Franklin, TN

1550 W McEwen Dr.
Suite 300
Franklin, TN 37067

(615) 814-4550

Daphne, AL

6384 Bayfront Park Dr. Suite B
Daphne, AL 36526

(251) 405-3553
Scroll to Top